The Freedom of an Armed Society

By FIRMIN DEBRABANDER

Note: This originally appeared in The New York Times on Monday. — efc

The night of the shootings at Sandy Hook Elementary School in Newtown, Conn., I was in the car with my wife and children, working out details for our eldest son’s 12th birthday the following Sunday — convening a group of friends at a showing of the film  “The Hobbit.” The memory of the Aurora movie theatre massacre was fresh in his mind, so he was concerned that it not be a late night showing. At that moment, like so many families, my wife and I were weighing whether to turn on the radio and expose our children to coverage of the school shootings in Connecticut. We did. The car was silent in the face of the flood of gory details. When the story was over, there was a long thoughtful pause in the back of the car. Then my eldest son asked if he could be homeschooled.

.223 caliber Bushmaster semiautomatic rifle, which was used to commit the massacre at the Sandy Hook Elementary School. Also known as an M4, this is an assault weapon, and we are told it was legally owned by the the killer's mother.
This is a .223 caliber Bushmaster semiautomatic rifle, which was used to commit the massacre at the Sandy Hook Elementary School. Also known as an M4, this is an assault weapon designed for military use — and we are told it was legally owned by the the killer’s mother. That’s probably true.

An armed society is the opposite of a civil society.

That incident brought home to me what I have always suspected, but found difficult to articulate: an armed society — especially as we prosecute it at the moment in this country — is the opposite of a civil society.

The Newtown shootings occurred at a peculiar time in gun rights history in this nation. On one hand, since the mid 1970s, fewer households each year on average have had a gun. Gun control advocates should be cheered by that news, but it is eclipsed by a flurry of contrary developments. As has been well publicized, gun sales have steadily risen over the past few years, and spiked with each of Obama’s election victories.

Read more